gimme-five | The blog of a busy guy.



Rant about the Birther Movement

The birther movement is insane.  There can be no reasonable person who believes Barack Obama was born outside of the United States after he produced a long-form birth certificate showing he was born in Hawaii.  It’s surprising anyone questioned it to begin with.  But according to a Wall Street Journal poll conducted today, 27.9% out of 10,354 people stated that the release of Obama’s birth certificate did not settle questions about his citizenship.  In other words, they think the certificate is a fake.  They think that the President of the United States of America forged a birth certificate.  Are you KIDDING me?  That sounds like something a 16-year-old kid would do on photoshop, not the most powerful person in the world.

And this poll was conducted on the Wall Street Journal’s website.  The Wall Street Journal is regarded as a very high-quality publication, and the people who read it are considered to be some of the smarter individuals who read newspapers.  I’m not saying it’s true, but I think we can all agree that regular readers of the WSJ are not dummies.  Yet around 28% of WSJ’s readers think this birther movement is legitimate.

Why?  Well in addition to the fact that most WSJ readers are relatively intelligent, the paper also tends to have a large conservative readership.  So my only thought is that these readers are so immersed in being conservative that they ignore facts and vote in the poll in whatever way suits their political interest.

Additionally, Donald Trump is essentially running on a platform of being a birther and nothing else.  But some polls have him LEADING THE 2012 REPUBLICAN NOMINATION RACE RIGHT NOW.  Really?  He’s running during a time of extreme fiscal crisis, yet has a record of personal and business BANKRUPTCY.  What good does he bring to the table?  Holy crap.

And of all the things to criticize someone about, focusing on the citizenship requirement for being a president has to be one of the pettiest.  Yes, it’s a constitutional requirement, and yes, you have to satisfy constitutional requirements to be President.  But do we gain much from prohibiting non-citizens from becoming president?  Many people who are born in the United States take this country for granted.  Many who immigrate to the United States do not, and love their country more than those who have lived here for their entire life.  Is there a valid policy reason for prohibiting non-citizens, perhaps those who love the United States more than anything else, from becoming president?  Do we really have some secret fantasy that “foreigners” will become president and destroy the US in favor of their former country?  Won’t people with evil intent or fake love for the country be rooted out in the extremely-invasive election process?

The same exact thing happens with people on the left attacking people on the right unfairly.  But the birther movement has to be the most crazy recent example.

RSS Feed

3 Comments for Rant about the Birther Movement

Lentenlands | April 28, 2011 at 1:03 am

We must examine the evidence and draw conclusions based upon observations. The document is clearly a fake.

People can draw their own conclusions beyond that, but a scientific methodical examination of the document reveals forgery.

“Condemnation without investigation is the height of ignorance.” —Albert Einstein

George | April 28, 2011 at 9:44 am

Your argument is not persuasive at all.

The blog post you link to includes plenty of half-made, conspiracy type arguments. Such as “I could write a five page [sic] essay pointing out the digital artifacts proving forgery on this form.” OK, where’s the five-page essay? And “[t]his fake is so bad that about the only conclusion you can draw is that the elites want the public to know it’s a fake to perpetuate the controversy.” How does this prove it’s a fake?

Your argument about “clipping masks” is also conveniently incomplete – we’re told to “google” clipping masks to understand why they’re significant. You’ll have to help me on showing me why those are significant and matter – particularly because this document is a compressed *.jpg to begin with – which naturally is going to have digital artifacts on it.

I understand and agree with your Einstein quote. But I’ll remind you that humans only have 24 hours in the day, and I’ve got lots of stuff to investigate. Investigating a conspiracy theory with very little policy basis behind it (keeping foreign-born people out of office) and very shaky foundations is not worth my time, nor should it dominate the TV coverage. We have real problems to worry about, and should not be wasting our time with this.

Caesar | January 22, 2013 at 11:21 am

Barack Hussein Obama is an illegal alien.




Theme Design by